• Teismų praktika

Alcohol turned into water in a customs warehouse: who pays the customs bill?

August 28, 2022
en lt
Alcohol turned into water in a customs warehouse: who pays the customs bill?

Photo by Charles "Duck" Unitas on Unsplash

A customs warehouse stored bottled alcohol (vodka). Customs audited the warehouse, took a sample, and found that there was water instead of vodka in the bottles! Customs ordered the warehouse to pay €308,455 customs debt (import duties and taxes, fines and interest). A dispute arose regarding who must pay the customs debt, as the customs warehouse is not obliged to take samples of the goods. Let's look at the clarification of the Supreme Administrative Court of Lithuania (SACL) in this case.

ARBA

Skaityti straipsnį

Open for free

Komentarai ()

Panašus turinys

Topic spotlight
icon
Criterion of financial solvency for the reduction or waiver of a comprehensive guarantee
2025-01-14

This article deals with legal changes in relation to the criterion of financial solvency that were introduced in 2018 but have not yet been noticed by many traders and taken into account by some … customs authorities. These changes allow for a more flexible approach to the assessment of economic operators' financial solvency when authorisations for a reduction or waiver of a comprehensive guarantee are requested or to be maintained.

Michael Lux

€
duties, taxes, law
Topic spotlight
icon
Criterion of financial solvency for the reduction or waiver of a comprehensive guarantee
2025-01-14

This article deals with legal changes in relation to the criterion of financial solvency that were introduced in 2018 but have not yet been noticed by many traders and taken into account by some customs authorities. These changes allow for a more flexible approach to the assessment of economic operators' financial solvency when authorisations for a reduction or waiver of a comprehensive guarantee are requested or to be maintained.

Michael Lux

€
duties, taxes, law
Case law
icon
Confiscation of third-party goods in case of unintentional customs infringement: CJEU interpretation
2025-01-09

Nobody likes to be penalised - whether you are an importer, a customs broker, or just a driver taking goods across the border. The penalty is a negative consequence for any person who has committed … the offence. It is clear when a person deliberately does something illegal to benefit from it. But what about those who do not intend to break the law but do so inadvertently? Do the negative consequences only affect the person who directly committed the offence? This article seeks to answer these and other questions about the penalties for customs offences in the EU.

Dr Ilona Mishchenko

€
violations, law
Case law
icon
Confiscation of third-party goods in case of unintentional customs infringement: CJEU interpretation
2025-01-09

Nobody likes to be penalised - whether you are an importer, a customs broker, or just a driver taking goods across the border. The penalty is a negative consequence for any person who has committed the offence. It is clear when a person deliberately does something illegal to benefit from it. But what about those who do not intend to break the law but do so inadvertently? Do the negative consequences only affect the person who directly committed the offence? This article seeks to answer these and other questions about the penalties for customs offences in the EU.

Dr Ilona Mishchenko

€
violations, law
Country update
icon
A wild goose chase: on the Israeli 'passing-on' condition when claiming a duty refund
2024-12-29

Overpayment of customs duties or other import duties can be a major burden for importers. There can be various reasons for overpayments, e.g. disputes over classification, valuation, origin, … etc. Reclaiming these duties from customs authority can be a lengthy and expensive process. The outcome is, of course, unpredictable. In Israel, there is an additional obstacle between the importer and the refund, the so-called ‘passing-on’ condition. This is not unique to Israel, but does not exist in the EU.

Omer Wagner

€
duties, taxes, law
Country update
icon
A wild goose chase: on the Israeli 'passing-on' condition when claiming a duty refund
2024-12-29

Overpayment of customs duties or other import duties can be a major burden for importers. There can be various reasons for overpayments, e.g. disputes over classification, valuation, origin, etc. Reclaiming these duties from customs authority can be a lengthy and expensive process. The outcome is, of course, unpredictable. In Israel, there is an additional obstacle between the importer and the refund, the so-called ‘passing-on’ condition. This is not unique to Israel, but does not exist in the EU.

Omer Wagner

€
duties, taxes, law
Case law
icon
EU regulations do not have a retroactive effect, but the measures they repeal do
2024-11-10

Do EU rules have a retroactive effect? There is no clear answer to this question. It has been the subject of a number of rulings by the Court of Justice of the EU in relation to specific acts … and situations. This article reviews one of the recent CJEU's judgments on this issue. It concerns the retroactive application of anti-dumping duties when they have already been repealed.

Dr Ilona Mishchenko

€
duties, taxes, law
Case law
icon
EU regulations do not have a retroactive effect, but the measures they repeal do
2024-11-10

Do EU rules have a retroactive effect? There is no clear answer to this question. It has been the subject of a number of rulings by the Court of Justice of the EU in relation to specific acts and situations. This article reviews one of the recent CJEU's judgments on this issue. It concerns the retroactive application of anti-dumping duties when they have already been repealed.

Dr Ilona Mishchenko

€
duties, taxes, law
Perspective
icon
EU sanctions system and the new Customs Code
2024-10-27

The topic of sanctions is of particular importance in EU Customs Law, as sanctions are relevant tools for ensuring the proper enforcement of the latter in EU Member States. In this regard, the … Proposal of 17 May 2023 for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing the Union Customs Code and the European Union Customs Authority, and repealing Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, highlights the negative effects of the lack of harmonization in terms of customs sanctions. It is emphasized therein that customs penalties vary greatly across Member States and are subject to evolution over time; in addition, the significant divergences between Member States in the application of sanctions against breaches of customs legislation can lead to a distortion of competition, loopholes and “customs shopping”.

Prof Fabrizio Vismara

€
violations
Perspective
icon
EU sanctions system and the new Customs Code
2024-10-27

The topic of sanctions is of particular importance in EU Customs Law, as sanctions are relevant tools for ensuring the proper enforcement of the latter in EU Member States. In this regard, the Proposal of 17 May 2023 for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing the Union Customs Code and the European Union Customs Authority, and repealing Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, highlights the negative effects of the lack of harmonization in terms of customs sanctions. It is emphasized therein that customs penalties vary greatly across Member States and are subject to evolution over time; in addition, the significant divergences between Member States in the application of sanctions against breaches of customs legislation can lead to a distortion of competition, loopholes and “customs shopping”.

Prof Fabrizio Vismara

€
violations
support@customsclear.net +37066426393 37066426393 (LT) +37064465553
Prisijungti Registruotis
Pamiršote slaptažodį?

* Pažymėti laukai privalomi

Sutinku su Terminai ir Sąlygos  ir Privatumo politika

Slaptažodžio priminimas

Slaptažodžio priminimas išsiųstas
Login with Google Login with LinkedIn
Susisiekite su mumis

Susisiekite su mumis

Ačiū už pranešimą
Maksimalus failo dydis 6 mb.
Failas per didelis